Mystery Box
Mystery Box
Mystery Box

Mystery Box

Feeling lucky? You should.

Regular price $75 Sale price$49 Save $26

Prime Supply Day Exclusive! With the Mystery Box you can save up to 43% on some of our best-selling gear. Find out what’s inside your box when you open it. Don’t love it? Don’t sweat. You can return it for a full refund.

But we doubt you’ll want to. Each box is filled with a mix of our all-natural skincare and shaving accessories backed by our lifetime warranty.
  • Box 1 – Regular Price $75 – Mystery Special $49
  • Box 2 – Regular Price $122 – Mystery Special $69
  • Box 3 – Regular Price $156 – Mystery Special $89

    Customer Reviews

    Based on 15 reviews
    Great deal

    If you are looking for a variety of stuff to try from Supply but have no idea where to start this is a great spot.

    Robert Timm
    All Good

    Excellent grouping. Love all the products.

    Michael Kenney
    Mystery Box Joy!

    Really been enjoying my experience with Supply, first old school razor I can use without cutting my face up (hand tremors). Took a chance on the recent mystery box and was very pleasantly surprised at what I received. With my initial kit, I'd ordered the marble shaving bowl. It's been awesome. Imagine my surprise when part of the mystery box was a matching marble tray and tumbler! They look great on my sink. Also had a new shaving brush (matte black finish to match my razor!) and some shaving cream, face scrub and eye cream in scents I hadn't tried yet. Already found a new favorite shave cream.

    Really like the new packaging for the shaving cream as well.

    All in all, well worth the price. Also, I have a sneaking suspicion they tailored the box to what I'd already ordered. Only duplicate item was the eye cream, but I was running low on that so good timing!

    Carl Miller
    Wonderful surprise

    The shave brush is as wonderful as advertised. Thanks

    Excellent customer service

    Supply customer service is prompt to respond and genuinely cares about this customers. Thanks again!

    Awesome Deal

    Absolutely love the Marble Tray, Silvertip Synthetic Shaving Brush, Eye Cream, Multi Purpose Moisturizer & the Feel Good Face Wash. The skin care products are amazing & their price points are excellent. The face wash is a great pre-shave prep! The Ultra Lather Shave Cream is the best one I've ever used. The only odd item was a Marble Tumbler. To deep to use for shave Cream & too large/heavy for anything shave related. Fantastic deal for the $$$!

    Ponce Gonzalez
    Mystery Box

    It had everything I needed and nothing that I didn’t need. I love the shaving cream.

    Darren Reeves
    Supply Surprise!

    I picked up the large surprise box from Supply. This is a great way to try a variety of awesome Supply products to see what you may like. Great idea. Really cool products that actually work!

    Craig Tellalian

    Nice box - could have skipped the eye cream

    Christopher Nelson
    Useful stuff

    I liked it because it was all stuff I'm going to be able to use. Only reason it's not 5 stars is that a couple things I sort of now have double of - but hey - it's a mystery box and I figured that could happen! Still a great value!